| |
Exploring
the online wilderness
"I am not a teacher, but a fellow traveler of whom you asked
the way."
George Bernard Shaw
Online teaching may seem like being in the wilderness to some instructors.
Venturing into wild, unknown territory. Overcome by fear, uncertainty
and paralysis. Hence the metaphor of the online classroom as an
unknown wilderness for the uninitiated. Instructors in the online
classroom need to impart a sense of familiarity with the new learning
medium and "transfer that level of comfort to the learners." (Palloff
& Pratt, 1999) They must convey a sense of confidence to those they
are in charge of. That they've been through this already and there's
nothing to fear. Like wilderness guides who inspire and encourage
their groups before setting out into new and often bewildering surroundings,
the online instructor must know when to guide the way to new learning
possibilities as well as when to step back and let the students
explore on their own.
Those new to the wilderness experience, no longer surrounded by
walls and modern conveniences, might ask: "Where's the bathroom?
How will I eat? How will I protect myself from the elements?" Online
instructors may experience similar feelings, no longer bound by
the constraints of the walled classroom. Many previous rules and
constraints no longer apply in cyberspace: "Where are the
students? How do I know if they're here or not? How can I
be sure they're participating? How can I evaluate them if
I can't see them?"
The teacher's role in online learning can be seen as that of a wilderness
guide. Wilderness guides have to lead the way for their inexperienced
campers, yet they also point out things along the way and allow
hikers to explore things and discover the wonders of nature themselves.
When setting up camp, the guide will initially demonstrate the proper
way to do things. Then as the students become familiar with the
way things go, guides step back and allow the campers to perform
duties themselves. Their interactions become collaborative: sharing
information, demonstrating things and cooperating amongst themselves
in order to carry out the tasks.
Online teachers must also initially lead the way, providing structure
to the course by establishing clear boundaries of what's expected
of the students. Too often erroneous assumptions are made by both
teacher and learner. Without specifically addressing issues, each
group's expectations may not mesh. The conflict inevitable during
this "forming and norming" (Palloff & Pratt, 1999) period should
not be avoided, as group cohesion ultimately depends on its successful
resolution. Again this parallels the wilderness situations where
solidarity is so important. Conflict stemming from such boundary
stetting is not necessarily a bad thing, done with respectful and
non-malicious intent. Once students' understand the new boundaries
of the online classroom, the teacher can step back and become more
of a facilitator. Pointing the way by proving relevant links, encouraging
expansive, topic-driven discussions, and assigning tasks that are
collaborative and meaningful.
Another way online approximates guided wilderness expeditions is
that both open avenues of communication that weren't previously
accessible. In the wilderness, we always seem to hear about the
city folk who look like they've never been off the sidewalk in their
lives suddenly bonding with people from contrasting backgrounds.
The lifting of social barriers enables communication that would
be nearly impossible back in the hectic concrete jungles. They seem
to thrive in such a new environment where they can let their guard
down and let their "true" selves come out. The removal of time and
space limitations in the online classroom similarly allows students
to "engage with each other, (the) material and instructor in completely
different ways." (Palloff & Pratt, 1999) All discussions between
students are open to all to read and comment on, as are the instructor's
reactions and comments to them. It's like having a bird's eye view
of a class, where all classroom communication can be heard. The
asynchronous nature of classroom discussion means that thoughtful
reflections are elicited, providing richer and deeper levels of
interaction.
Instructors contemplating stepping into the online classroom need
not be overly anxious about making the leap. By providing enough
initial structure and then stepping back to let students become
explorers, a sense of discovery can be had by all participants.
Online teachers and learners will experience a transformation similar
to wilderness returnees who say their lives will never be the same.
Instructors will move from spoon-feeding information in the face
to face class to showing students where the ingredients and utensils
are. Lastly, there is one key difference between a true wilderness
and the online classroom for which we can all be thankful for: mosquitoes!
(1) Palloff, Rena M. and Keith Pratt, Building Learning
Communities in Cyberspace: Effective Strategies for the Online Classroom.
San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass, 1999.
John Griffin is a student in the Masters of Science in Education,Online
Teaching and Learning program at California State University Hayward.
He currently teaches ESL at TheUniversity of Seoul in South Korea.
An ex-U.S. Forest Service wilderness ranger, his love of the outdoors
led him to see the relationship between an online teacher and wilderness
guide, leading others into unknown territory.
|